Victorian Refs II - The Good, The Bad and The Ugly

[rubber balls]

Hate to try and have a discussion about the umpiring quality in Victoria without people getting on their high horses and 'closing' the thread.
Is beening critical too hard for the refs to handle?
Considering that refs nowadays seem to be having more and more impact on both the flow and the final outcome of games I feel it is only fair to let people discuss the quality of ref'ing.

Anyway the question still remains....

Who is the best Victorian ref?
Who is the worst ref?
Who is the ugliest ref?
Who is the most biased ref?

[roycegracie47]

When a moderator closes a thread for a specific reason (in this case slander), you are not entitled to make a new one without permission or bash said mod for closing it.

[KnightsLAXDad]

Hate to try and have a discussion about the umpiring quality in Victoria without people getting on their high horses and 'closing' the thread.
Is beening critical too hard for the refs to handle?
Considering that refs nowadays seem to be having more and more impact on both the flow and the final outcome of games I feel it is only fair to let people discuss the quality of ref'ing.

Anyway the question still remains....

Who is the best Victorian ref?
Who is the worst ref?
Who is the ugliest ref?
Who is the most biased ref?

rubber balls - how could this be a fair discussion if none of the refs are here to discuss (defend) their actions??

worst? ugliest? biased? These are hardly reasonable items to discuss and can rarely, if ever, be backed up with fact. This kind of discussion will only lead to whining, moaning, and outright flaming.


KLD